-
Measuring a Concentration of Power
Introduction In the last few years, ‘an AI-enabled concentration of power’ has become a common expression in the AI-governance lexicon, and it has been put to use in quite a few situations. The misuse of advanced capabilities by malicious actors could lead to one (Brundage et al., 2018). So could centralised control over compute, which… Read more
-
On Scenario Politics
Introduction The AI Futures Project wrote a “Plan A”, a positive vision for “what should happen” until 2040. It outlines goals – the solution of five big problems: (“Loss of control to superintelligent AIs; “AI leading to massive concentration of power into whatever group controls the first superintelligences (if anyone)”; “World War 3 risk due… Read more
-
Hand Loom Weavers, 1837
Acemoglu and Johnson, in a paper on hand loom weavers’ wages in the early 19th century say: “Recognizing the essential role of choice over the direction of technology and organizational forms is not only relevant for understanding the early decades of the Industrial Revolution; it is also critical to appreciate how and why things started… Read more
-
Notes on technological determinism
In a previous blog post about the industrial revolution as an analogy for AI, I wrote a bit about how someone might end up with a monocausal narrative about what happened between 1750 and now: one that starts with the invention of the steam engine and other technologies and ends with everything else, “revolutions of all… Read more
-
The Industrial Revolution Isn’t What It Used To Be
In a widely cited blogpost called “How big a deal was the industrial revolution?” Luke Muehlhauser asks a rhetorical, but important, question: what collection of events is that? Leaving aside current disputes about what a “helpful” definition of the industrial revolution should be, below is a brief exploration of the origin of the phrase. Raymond… Read more
-
Power: An Oversimplified View
I’ve been reading Steven Lukes “Power, a radical view”. A number of things from the book seem notable in the context of the recent Anthropic-fable-debacle. (Here is an opinionated summary from Dean Ball, for those who haven’t followed it) – So here is a short and oversimplified summary. The book itself provides an overview of… Read more